The Ultimate Loaded Peanut Butter Cookies PLUS HERSHEY’S #Giveaway #BunnyTrail

 I was provided with candy by HERSHEY’S as well as a stipend from The Global Influence Network as part of my participation in this campaign. All thoughts and ideas are my own.


I have so much fun celebrating Easter every year. While I know the meaning of Easter isn’t coloring eggs and sitting on laps of rabbits I do enjoy that side of the holiday. The one great thing about spacing your children so far apart is that you never have to stop the fun. For 13 years now I’ve had the fun of candy filled Easter baskets, pictures with the Easter Bunny & countless egg hunts.

The Ultimate Loaded Peanut Butter Cookies

Of course everyone’s favorite part is the boatloads of candy that enter the house. Thanks to HERSHEY’S my house filled up sooner than later. I recently shared with you my favorite cookie recipe ever for Peanut Butter Cookies and, um,  well, I’ve  sorta become addicted to them. I’ve made them over and over and over again.

The Ultimate Loaded Peanut Butter Cookies

Then one day I was making my favorite cookies yet again while thinking these couldn’t get any better if I tried…. or could they? I looked into my baking cabinet and found where I had hidden some REESE’S Reester Bunnies. I knew if I left them out on the counter they’d be gone before I could do something with them and this was the perfect idea. While I was in there I also grabbed some HEATH Toffee Bits and some REESE’s peanut butter chips.


My husband is a huuuuuuuuge REESE’S fan and every Easter I buy him a big REESE’S Egg but this year I thought I’d make him some cookies. How cute are these REESE’S Reester bunnies?


It was almost a shame I had to chop them up. Almost.

 When I chopped them up I left them chunky. I wanted you to be able to tell you had a mouth full of a REESE’S when you ate a bite.


Add them into the batter along with some REESE’S peanut butter chips and some HEATH toffee bits. Doesn’t that look good? Mmmmmm.

The Ultimate Loaded Peanut Butter Cookies Batter

Take a scoop and place them on a non stick baking pan. I recommend Silpat’s for the perfect cookie.

The Ultimate Loaded Peanut Butter Cookies

Don’t forget to grab your fork and criss-cross them. Somehow I always forget to do this. It’s what makes any peanut butter cookie official.

The Ultimate Loaded Peanut Butter Cookies

The Ultimate Loaded Peanut Butter Cookies

To make these fabulous cookies you’ll need to make my Peanut Butter Cookies as it to batter then add in:

  • 1 Cup REESE’S Reesters (or PB Cups)
  • 1 Cup REESE’S Peanut Butter Chips
  • 1/4 Cup HEATH Toffee Bits

Then bake at 350 for 15 minutes or until golden on the edges. Let cool for 10 minutes and then move to wire rack until completely cooled. If you want to not fight people off hide them immediately in an air tight container. Enjoy!

The Ultimate Loaded Peanut Butter Cookies

Right now one (1) Mom Spotted readers has the opportunity to win an assortment of HERSHEY’S candies. To enter use the Rafflecopter form below. Good Luck!
a Rafflecopter giveaway

Contest ends 4.21.14 at 11:59pm. For Official Giveaway Rules click here. U.S. Residents Only
About Jennifer

Jennifer, the mom behind the Mom Spotted blog, is located in Western Ma. She has three boys, Johnny (13), Gavin (7), & Sawyer (2). She is married to her high school sweetheart. On Mom Spotted you'll find a fun selection of recipes, family fun, product reviews, and more! You can also find her on twitter @MomSpotted and Facebook.


  1. We always do egg hunts. When weather did not cooperate we had our hunt indoors. Lesson learned, make a list if you are hiding real eggs.
    Love the Coconut Marshmallow Nests recipe

  2. christine jessamine says:

    I love to do easter egg hunts with our kids. I would love to make the birds nest cupcakes!

  3. Every year, I hide my kids’ baskets and love watching them search all over for their goodies! And I think the Hershey’s Kisses Mice are adorable!

    coriwestphal at msn dot com

  4. We enjoy making Resurrection Rolls as an Easter tradition and I like the Easter Basket cupcakes recipe :-)

  5. We have a big family Easter dinner together and have a wonderful time visiting together.

Add Your Comment