35 Pie Recipes You Need to Make

I can’t believe how fast time has flown! My little boy turns FOUR today! It wasn’t until I had a baby on Pi day that we started celebrating the day! I had no pie recipes and had never even made a pie before! Now we save the cake for Sawyer’s birthday party and always make sure to blow his candles out to pie on the big day.

Me & Sawyer

As you can imagine there are a lot of different kinds of pie to choose from. I thought I’d put this big list of the best pie recipes I could find to share with you. Now the hardest part is to figure out which ones I want to make first!

No Bake Blueberry Custard Pie (vegan + gluten free)

This No Bake Blueberry Custard Pie (vegan + gluten free) looks absolutely amazing! There are more gluten free & vegan pies than I realized!


Love cookies? Combine your love of pie and cookies with this Chocolate Chip Pie! Or try a different kind of cookie:

Old Fashioned Banana Cream Pie

While I love a lot of different pies my favorite is a good Old Fashioned Banana Cream Pie! There are so many different ways to make a banana pie, though. These are just a few of the ways:

Sweet Cherry Pie with Toasted Almonds a

I’m a huge fruit pie lover and this Sweet Cherry Pie with Toasted Almonds is no exception. Besides the obvious apple pie, here are some great other fruit pies:

Peanut Butter Pie

My husband is a PB guy all the way! This Peanut Butter Pie would be the first one on the table he’d be reaching for too!


My favorite flavor anything is always Almond Joy so when I saw this Almond Joy Pie I knew it was on the must-make list! Other great candy bar pies are:


This Crack Pie looks pretty addicting which is how it likely got its name. Cream pies are popular and come in many flavors:

Pie Recipes You Need to Make

Like these Pie Recipes? Which would you make first?


  1. vickie couturier says

    oh my goodness those look so so good,,made my stomach growl,,lol,,,did you make most of these?

    • Jennifer says

      I didn’t make any of these, but I’m going to! I think I reall want to try that Banana Cream one featured! That’s my favorite kinda pie!

  2. The chocolate chip pie reminds me of the Tollhouse Pie, and it’s one of my favorites! I haven’t tried the Crack pie yet, but plan to one of these days—-I have the recipe from the Momofuku Milk Bar cookbook!

  3. Cynthia R says

    These pies look and sound amazing. I think I would make the Dulce De Leche Banana Cream Pie first.

  4. Angela Ingles says

    I just pinned this post. There’s just too much goodness here NOT to pin this post. The sweet cherry pie with toasted almonds, the chocolate peanut butter pie . . . oh my gosh yum!

  5. Leigh Anne Borders says

    I am definitely a pie girl. I enjoy anything lemon, but there are so many other great ones too!

  6. Edye says

    I love me some pie! All of these look amazing; I don’t know which one to try first 🙂

  7. That peanut butter pie looks so amazing.

Add Your Comment